Which Waterfront Lifestyle Fits You Best? Edmonds or West Seattle?
For anyone dreaming of life by the water, Edmonds and West Seattle are two standout options in the greater Seattle area. Both offer access to stunning views, water activities, and vibrant communities, but each delivers a very different lifestyle. Choosing between them comes down to more than just location—it’s about deciding which pace, culture, and amenities fit your vision of home.
Edmonds
Edmonds sits about 15 miles north of Seattle and exudes small-town charm. Its downtown is pedestrian-friendly, with an array of local shops, art galleries, and restaurants that range from casual cafes to fine dining with waterfront views. The community is known for its active arts scene, regular farmers’ markets, and annual events that bring residents together. Living here also means easy access to the Edmonds-Kingston ferry, opening the door to weekend adventures on the Olympic Peninsula.
The pace of life in Edmonds is slower and more relaxed, appealing to retirees, families, and those who value quiet evenings and close-knit connections. Its real estate market is characterized by limited inventory, which can create competitive situations for well-located properties, especially those with water views. Many of the homes here are single-family residences with generous yards, though condos and townhomes are also available for those seeking lower-maintenance living.
West Seattle
West Seattle, in contrast, offers a more urban waterfront experience. Located just across Elliott Bay from downtown Seattle, it’s known for its laid-back vibe, sandy beaches, and some of the best city views you’ll find anywhere. Alki Beach is the centerpiece, attracting locals and visitors alike for jogging, biking, kayaking, and sunset watching. The reopening of the West Seattle Bridge has made commuting to downtown more manageable, increasing interest in this already desirable neighborhood.
West Seattle offers more variety in terms of housing. From modern condos and apartments to historic Craftsman homes, there’s something to suit a wide range of tastes and budgets. Its closer proximity to downtown Seattle makes it attractive to young professionals, while the strong sense of community, excellent schools, and access to outdoor recreation appeal to families as well.
Market Trends
Market trends in both areas show steady demand, but the drivers are different. In Edmonds, scarcity plays a significant role—there’s only so much waterfront, and buyers who want it are willing to compete. In West Seattle, demand has surged since the bridge reopening, and homes in neighborhoods like Admiral, Alaska Junction, and Fauntleroy are drawing strong interest.
When weighing the two, consider your daily lifestyle needs. Edmonds offers a quieter, more predictable environment, with easy access to beaches, marinas, and nature trails. It’s ideal for those who want a slower pace without sacrificing amenities. West Seattle provides a balance between waterfront relaxation and big-city convenience, with plenty of dining, shopping, and cultural activities at your fingertips.
Buyers in both markets should be prepared to act quickly when they find the right home. Pre-approval is essential, and working with an agent who knows the nuances of each neighborhood can give you a competitive advantage. Sellers, on the other hand, should focus on presentation. Whether you’re in Edmonds or West Seattle, well-staged homes with professional photography are more likely to attract multiple offers and achieve top-dollar sales.
Looking Ahead?
Looking ahead, both markets are expected to remain strong. Edmonds will likely continue to see limited supply and consistent demand, keeping prices steady or rising. West Seattle’s recovery from the bridge closure, combined with its ongoing popularity, suggests continued growth in both sales volume and prices.
If you’re torn between these two waterfront lifestyles, the best way to decide is to experience them firsthand. Spend a weekend exploring Edmonds’ downtown, strolling its beaches, and chatting with locals. Then do the same in West Seattle—walk Alki, visit The Junction, and take in the energy of the community.
Laura Sinclair can help you compare both areas in detail, showing you homes that match your budget, style, and lifestyle goals. Whether you end up falling for Edmonds’ charm or West Seattle’s vibrancy, you’ll have the guidance you need to make an informed choice. Start your search at LauraSinclairHomes.com and find the waterfront home that’s perfect for you.